[00:00:00] Speaker A: Foreign.
Hi and welcome all to the Maidan Podcast. My name is Robert Zayd Kianori Zigmund. I am an editorial and project associate here at the Maidan and at the Abu Suleiman center for Global Islamic Studies. We are very grateful today to be joined by Dr. Farah Al Sharif, who is a writer, educator and research scholar.
She received her PhD from Harvard University, where she specialized in West African intellectual Islamic history, studying under Dr. Usman Kain and other renowned faculty. She earned degrees from the Graduate Theological Union in Berkeley, California and Georgetown University School of Foreign Service, and has served as the Associate Director of the Abbasi Program in Islamic Studies at Stanford University and was also a visiting scholar there. She specializes in the study of Islam, West African Islam, Sufism, the nation state, colonialism, and intellectual history.
She is widely published in both academic and journalistic publications and she regularly writes on her substack Sermons at the Court at
[email protected] Dr. Farah, thank you so much for being with us.
[00:01:23] Speaker B: Thank you so much for having me. Robert,
[00:01:26] Speaker A: we are very grateful to have you here. I wanted to give you an opportunity. Obviously, we will talk more about your research as we move further into the conversation, but especially in the context of the televised genocide that we've all been watching for the last three years, I wanted to give you an opportunity to talk about your Palestinian heritage and how that has impacted both your personal and academic journeys.
[00:01:56] Speaker B: All right, bismillahirrahmanirrahim. It's an honor to be with you today. I'm very grateful for the invitation.
So it's very difficult to talk about Palestine because it feels like you are talking about your very heart, you know.
So I grew up in Amman, Jordan, and very much part of the open wound right of the Palestinian diaspora and the disenchantment of living right next door to your occupied homeland. So living in this mirage called the post colonial nation state. So it always felt unnatural for life to resume kind of as normal when there was nothing really normal about an occupation next door, about Muhammad Al Durra, about the intifada, about not being able to go there to pray at Al Aqsa, to give Nusra support and aid to our brothers and sisters.
And that horrific situation, this dystopia, this myth of the post colonial has only become more and more grotesque and more absurd now with this genocide, this, this lifestream genocide. And I think none of us really have been left unchanged after that. Like the world will never return to what it was. And in a way that is a blessing in Disguise Alhamdulillah.
It is better to see the painful truth than return to the lulling, you know, sweetness of lies and deception. So this exposure, this delineation, this Gaza has exposed so much of the moral rot of what I call the ruse based order or disorder really.
So Jazahumullah Ana Kulkhair, we can never thank them enough. Them and all the victims really of the war on terror, this ongoing war of terror that has been impacting Muslim majority communities worldwide, whether be it in Afghanistan or Iraq or Iran or Sudan or Somalia or Yemen or Libya or Syria.
So this is one long story that has been impacting all of us.
And kind of on a more personal level, when I think of Palestine, I think of this chant from the Sudanese revolution where they would say, the blood of the martyr is my blood and the mother of the martyr is my mother.
And I also remember, for example, the teachers of the Gaza genocide, the people who have awakened the Muslim Ummah from a sleepy slumber.
Someone like Waelid Dahduh, who, the journalist who has his family martyred and he's affectionately known as Al Jabal, you know, the mountain to most Ghazns because of his like gentle paternal strength. And when they asked him, you know, he had to go live after his son was martyred, Hamza. And he said these most thunderous words. And they really remind us of the times of the Seerah. They remind us of the times of the Futuhat. You know, they really brought back, they've really enlivened for us as Muslims what it means to be a Muslim. And he said, Hamza was all of me, right? And he said, and he was tearfully saying, these tears make us different than our enemies. We cry and shed tears because we are saturated with humanity.
So this is the kind of the nobility of what I call the Gazza school of humanity. Gazza has done more for Islam than any other Muslim cleric or jurist or alim in the 21st century.
They've revived the kind of the ethos of what it means to be a Muslim. It means to sacrifice for something greater than you, to rely on Allah when everybody else has abandoned you. So in theological terms, we can really say that Palestine represents the contented soul, whereas Israel and its benefactors really represent the maniacal, tormented soul that burns everything in its wake.
So, you know, this is something that is very painful, but we are also living in very, you know, it's a hinge moment in history where nothing will resume to the way it was before.
And so this is an Opportune time for us to realize the importance of this sacrifice and to ready ourselves for a different world.
[00:06:49] Speaker A: Thank you so much. Yes.
You discuss the concept of sumud in some of your writing, which.
Could you talk a little bit more about the concept of sumud, what it means to you, what it means in the context of Palestinian society, and then how that has.
How that has served maybe as a lens in your own work.
[00:07:14] Speaker B: Yeah. So this word sumud is fascinating because there's actually no English equivalent for it.
If I were to translate it, it is the kind of the encapsulation of stubborn perseverance and defiance with faith.
And it is as if this word is preserved for the Palestinian people alone, although, of course, it's used by other. In other contexts. But it came to kind of symbolize the Palestinian patience, the one that doesn't accept humiliation.
And it's a kind of, I think, the marker of this struggle, because its attachment kind of to the earth. Right. Sumud connotes this rootedness.
So if I were to describe it also in terms of imagery, sumud would be that millennia old olive tree. Right. Ravaged by fire, wind, and the harshest elements. And yet it stands. Right. And it keeps giving,
[00:08:25] Speaker A: relating to your family and kind of that heritage.
You recently engaged with the work of your great uncle, at least in one of the last few years.
How much did you know about your own family's legacy of scholarship, of activism and resistance before you kind of came into graduate studies or Islamic studies?
[00:08:52] Speaker B: Yeah. So growing up, I knew it was a very heavy legacy. I knew it was a tall order to try to emulate that or walk in those footsteps. But Alhamdulillah, someone like my great uncle, Kamal el Sharif, Rahmatullah Alayhi, Allah decreed it such that he would become one of my earliest mentors when I was a freshman at the American University in Cairo. He spent his retirement years there doing philanthropy work.
And so he had this very gentle, kind and prophetic nature about him. So typical of the awliya, the allies of God or the friends of God. When you spend time with them, your heart becomes transformed.
And so he really yanked me out of the kind of vapidness of the Westernized, you know, milieu of elite schools, and really reminded me of what's important in life now. This person who is so gentle and so loving in his demeanor, you would never be able to tell that he himself was born of great suffering and sacrifice.
You would never be able to tell that he actually led a Battalion in 1948 resisting Zionist and British Gangs in Palestine, in Gaza.
So naturally I would only find out more and more about him, this man of mystery. After his death and realizing the weight of the legacy that he carried and that inheritance, it really felt like a big amana, a trust for me to kind of read about him and read his work and Inshaallah tried to continue to build upon the shoulders of these giants. And so I think the text you're referring to that I translated parts of, he wrote Al Mughamara al Israeli AFI Ifriqiya. And it was about the Zionist soft power incursion into Africa in the age of post colonial independence. Now he wrote this as an ambassador to Nigeria and other surrounding countries which subhanallah later on my own father, Rahmatullah Alayhi would become ambassador in Morocco and Nigeria, Senegal and Mauritania. So you could say that West Africa and public engagement, politics, writing was always in my family's DNA, if you will. And I think my love of writing really came from the establishment of a newspaper in Jerusalem in the 50s, which later became, you know, morphed into becoming Jordan's first daily, first daily newspaper which my beloved father Ahmadullah became the editor in chief of.
So there's a mishmash of all of these elements that I think really informed my intellectual and spiritual formation and I'm very grateful for that. And ultimately none of us can control our destinies really. It's all divine providence,
[00:12:13] Speaker A: of course. Well, that is such a powerful legacy to inherit. And to hear that it kind of has unfolded in different ways and revealed itself at different stages of your life is very powerful.
You ultimately, in your dissertation you studied the, you focused on the Rima of Umar Tal and this document, extensive work. Obviously that's a much shortened version of the full title, which maybe you can speak to. But could you talk more about what drew you to his life and work in particular and to the Tijania community, Antarctica, which you spent time in person in West Africa. But could you speak to kind of where, how your journey kind of led you to that point?
[00:13:08] Speaker B: Yes, I think this focus on the Tijaniya and this magnum opus for my PhD at Harvard really came about from two sources. If I could summarize it. I think the first one was kind of a lived experience with powerful, state aligned, quote unquote Sufi scholars, if you could call it that.
I was fresh out of undergrad and I got this opportunity to work at the Royal Islamic Strategic Studies center. That's a mouthful in Amman, Jordan. But it was essentially a soft power tool to kind of promote a quote unquote, moderate traditional Islam juxtaposed with, you know, Islamism and other more quote unquote, like aberrant political.
More political groups. Right.
And so it was that eye opening experience which allowed me to really see ways in which state authorities, especially in the authoritarian Arab world, wanted to produce or manufacture good Islam and pit it against a bad Islam which resists a bad Islam that doesn't, you know, comply. Right.
And I witnessed that firsthand.
Now, I had more than just kind of a reactionary impetus to that, you could say, pernicious project. It was from a kind of a lived commitment to authentic tasawwuf that I saw juxtaposed to this state project.
For example, personally, my great grandmother was a sheikha in the Tsijaniya community in northern Sinai. And sheikha was a powerful matriarch who kind of raised my father. And he would tell me stories about her and her piety and her strength and her generosity and how she even gave counsel to the men of her village.
And so that led me down the rabbit hole of learning to Sowaf on its own terms, away from state propaganda, away from this kind of reactionary anxieties of trying to act as the good Muslim. And so for my master's degree, I ended up writing exactly about that, about manufacturing Islam light as Sufism, as good Islam.
And so I had already laid down the theoretical framework of how that happens. Why in the colonial era, they tried to. The colonial officers tried to pit two Islams against one another. And it was arguably, ironically, the Sufis that were considered the Muslim Brotherhood of today. They were. Actually, there are colonial archives that went after the so called Sufi brotherhoods for being too rebellious, too unmoored, too resistant, and too kind of stubborn. Right. In accepting the status quo.
So, long story short, how I get to Kitabur Ri Mah, it's the Kitabur Ri Mahbir Rahim al Anuhur Hizbar Rajm, which translates to the book of spears of the league of Allah the merciful upon the necks of the league of Satan the accursed. Again, a long mouthful.
And this was written by a very enigmatic, larger than life, a scholar named Hajj Omar Futi Tal who died in 1864.
Or, you know, if you're accepting the West African lore about him, he. He never really died because his body was never found.
So there is this kind of mystery surrounding his disappearance in the cave when he was in battle. Subhanallah. But this text is considered the second Most important primary text of the Tariqah Tijaniyya after the Jawahir Al Ma' Ani of Sheikh Ahmad Al Tijani.
And you know, this text has never been translated fully into English and there's been no full fleshed out conceptual study of it. And I'm pleased to announce that I signed advance contract with UNC Press on this work, inshallah.
It will come out hopefully sometime next year. And I entitled the work Soulcraft Abasulfi Jihad of Hajja Marshall.
[00:17:57] Speaker A: Yes.
[00:17:58] Speaker B: Yeah. So I'm excited to show really that there is no contradiction between the jihad of the self and jihad in the world. And that struggle is the name of the game for spiritual wayfaring and that the secularization of Islam and trying to divorce the two domains is a bida. Right. It's an innovation that isn't really there in the Islamic classical scholarship.
[00:18:26] Speaker A: Wow. Now that. That. That is a really powerful point that you're making. And the fact that I think that a lot of people have pretty much no exposure, if any, a lot of Muslims have no exposure to the richness of the West African Sufi tradition, the West African tradition at all.
You know, there are many towering figures which you reference in your work, from Ahmadu Bamba to Ibrahim Nas.
What do you think the reasons are for this neglect in.
Of the vibrant West African Muslim heritage and also specifically the role of Sufism in West Africa?
[00:19:08] Speaker B: Yeah, I've always said that this domain kind of rests in the. In a double blind spot. Right.
Kind of more normative. Contemporary Islamic scholarship has adopted the. More the modernist reaction to view tasawwaf as suspect, as too esoteric, as too metaphysical and an aberration. So it kind of.
There's that one blind spot and then there's the added blind spot of taking African Muslim intellectual production seriously due to racialized bias and othering, which is kind of really a product of the colonial experience.
Colonial othering, which again gets absorbed by osmosis.
In Muslim majority contexts, scholarly context today, and even in the academy, it is often said that this domain of study is often seen as too African for Islamicists and too Islamic for Africanists.
So it is kind of sad but not unexpected that this kind of scholarship gets disregarded. But what I find is that what we often ignore the most is often what we need the most. It has the most medicine.
And it is this otherization that prompted me to take this domain of study seriously, because I feel like there is something very antidotal and very healing in studying these preferably unheard Areas of study, especially in this very kind of racialized, supremacist kind of world order that we are inhabiting. Muslims are not innocent of that there is anti blackness in the attitudes of, be it in scholarship or in the Masajid or in the programs that we study. And who gets to speak on behalf of the Islamic tradition. That is such a timeless conundrum, right? And so what I find most antidotal and most generative in this study is that it can really help us see beyond reactionary clasps. So for example, if we study the 20th century intellectual history in the Muslim world, we often find many ulema who respond, right? They respond to modernity, they respond to Zionism or communism or whatever ism of the day.
But what we see when that happens is that reacting will always put us in a position of weakness because the very basis of the project is one of defensiveness.
By constantly responding to an external ideology, we often obscure the fact that, you know, Islam already offers a unique standalone project that can stand on its own in any era. And it doesn't need to have anxieties and it doesn't need to react to the isms because it represents embodied, organic, primordial way of knowing. So what I argue in my work is that being, just being is a very powerful and neglected way of approaching knowledge, of approaching oneself, of approaching modernity. And this is something that I really find very strongly in the likes of towering figures such as Sheikh Ahmadu Bamba or Sheikh Omar Tal or Sheikh Ibrahim Nias, is that their very being went against rampant epistemicide. I think the word epistemicide comes from the. The Portuguese sociologist Santos, who coined this term. But what epistemicide means is the act of silencing ways of knowing, primordial ways of knowing through intentional erasure, right? And so this is more than just like missing books or you know, burning of the libraries which we saw happen in Gaza, and we saw it happen in the Mongol era and many other times in Islamic history. But when we preserve these prophetic ways of knowing, we are the library, right? We are the Quran walking.
And so I think this is a powerful domain of knowing that I think we need to return to, to be able to face the storms of the times we are living in.
[00:24:08] Speaker A: You talk in, you write about how when Sheikh Nias was travel through Egypt, he passed through Azhar and there was a lot of skepticism, racism, this idea that, well, we got to ask, you know, how does. And trying to interrogate and in fact that they found that he was more knowledgeable than any of them really were, if I, if I understood it correctly. And then the point that you make is, I think, particularly striking is that he completed his studies without ever leaving West Africa. He didn't go study at the University of Medina. He didn't go to Al Azhar. He studied with West African scholars who had preserved the intellectual tradition of Islamic intellectual tradition in West Africa, which I think that when I read that, I found that particularly striking. That's not resonates as this sort of crisis of legitimacy that a lot of Muslims, I think are experiencing or feeling of. How do you prove that you're connected to the root? And it didn't seem that he had that anxiety that so many people have now.
[00:25:22] Speaker B: Yeah, it's fascinating and it's not atypical of the other West African sages and Allamas of his time and prior. Also the same thing. It's same lore with Sheikh Hajj Omar Futi, who also passed through Al Azhar on his way to Al Hajj.
And the same thing. He was met with suspicion and arrogance. And they quizzed him, you know, intensely on, you know, trying to get him to make a mistake or to show that, you know, oh, he's not Arab enough or not learned enough, but in fact ended up surpassing and even enumerating how many times specific letters appeared in the Quran, specific words. He would by numbers know them all like truly a marvel. And Shaykh Ibrahim was dubbed Shaykh al Islam at Al Azhar for just the vastness of his erudition that was, as you said, received in the heart of West Africa alone through the scholarly networks in the local community, through his father and the teachers there locally.
So the model of the West African Muslims is really resembling of a kind of an unapologetic kind of kingship that has always been tied to the African continent. When Sayyidina Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi wasallam sent his first community to safety in the first hijra, he sent them to a just African king right at the time he wasn't Muslim. But we always have to remember that in the pre colonial era, leadership and authority in the African continent was always tied to justice and nobility and protecting the weakness. And so we have to wrestle back what our imaginaries are right about our own.
African Islamic history is so rich. Most of the Quranic stories are based there.
We don't know that in the 19th century there was an African Islamic revolution in Africa that was based on Islamic scholarly principles. It was led by Al Mamis Imam states khilafas that centered upon themselves, you know, rule that was underpinned by Islamic scholarship and justice. And years before the French revolutions, we have someone like Cherno Suleiman Bal, who died in 1776. He led a revolt against the corrupt regime of his time to found these imam states and even went on to have an imprint on abolitionist history in Islam and kind of the. Yeah. And fighting slavery from within Islamic scholarly vantage points.
So it's an ocean, but it's all there. Alhamdulillah. It just needs to be talked about more. And I'm grateful for this platform and for your questions.
[00:28:45] Speaker A: One of the things that kind of gets brought up again and again when, when, when we look at.
And as you kind of positioned it, it's like, oh, Sufism as kind of this sterile, like domesticated idea that we see so much, especially in kind of even in State Department discourses about, okay, how can we fund group, you know, how can we uplift the safe, the, you know, Sufi that maybe they don't even identify it as a Muslim thing. It's a Sufism completely separated from the tradition.
I get to get at my question, specifically hearing what you're talking about with which. Which is this rich tradition.
You've talked a little bit about it, but I just want to try to tease it out a bit more. How do you see the role of, of Sufism in Muslim anti colonial resistance?
And then kind of from that, how can we address this, this gap if you, if we accept these categories of kind of quietest Sufism and then the historical reality, how, how do we, how do we address that gap as, as a kind of.
Yeah. As the part of how does the Muslim community address that gap?
[00:30:09] Speaker B: Yeah, it's a big question and I think about it a lot.
So just to give context to the listeners, as you said, Robert, rightly, that the word Sufism itself can also be.
Not also definitely be viewed as a product of colonial scholarship. I think Carl Ernst calls it a product of Orientalist zoology, meaning that similarly to how biologists would dissect certain creatures and try to give them categories and give different species different names. That is what the colonial apparatus and scholars who were studying the Muslim world through the Orientalist gaze gave the name of these more interiorly inclined Muslims the name Sufism. Right. As an ism, which it never really was like Tasawuwf has always been part and parcel of the normative way of knowing for Islam and Muslims.
It is born arguably out of the Ahlul sufa or of the Medina era, but even actually from the Quran and Sunnah itself, right?
You know, the utkuru, Allah, remember Allah a lot, right? And that the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam himself would do Tahajjud. And he is the teacher, he's the ultimate guide.
And so this idea that you can somehow separate this intensified love of God and this worship from the very heart of Islam, it is the very heart of Islam.
And so that is in the normative way of being Muslim. La ilaha illallah, Muhammad Rasulullah. When you say la ilaha illallah, you are denying all other other than God. And that is exactly what a so called Sufi is supposed to do, right? So I've described Sufism maybe a bit provocatively in my substack as a form of revolt. And I said that to kind of wrestle it out of the stasis of the categorical stasis that we're in. And I always have argued that ultimately Tasawwuf is a revolt against the Dunya, the allures of this world. It is a revolt against the self, against whims and egos and folly and jealousy and all these base kind of attachments, right? And it is also a revolt against convention and going against the grain of, you know, whatever is out there. You know, as Muslims, we are already the Ghuraba. We are already the strangers who don't quite fit in, right? So we should lean into that rather than out of that. And so see that as a blessing for us that we don't quite go with the flow, as they say, and we don't go with popular opinion. We're meant to hold up mirrors to the status quo, to societal moral decay.
And so also it is a revolt against the physical senses, right? We don't believe what Pharaoh tells us to see.
And the Shuhada, I like that they represent that worldview of continued life. And I'm not trying to glorify death in any way, but I'm saying that a mu' min is someone who puts the world of the worldview of transformation over the world of forms, and that there is something greater than this dunya and there's a greater power than all of this.
So going back to your question is how do I see the role of Sufism in anti colonial resistance? I think we just have to break that up and see how do we see the role of Ihsan and Tasawwuf in confronting the injustices of our times? Because that is something that every Muslim needs to think about whether Salafi, whether Sufi, whether any anybody on that spectrum. And I think that we need to remember that yes, once upon a time, those who were at the forefront of anti colonial resistance were these Sufi leaders, not in spite of their commitment to Tasawwuf, but because of it. Because they were debasing their self, because they put Allah over their fears. That made them shed their attachments to make them courageous enough to fulfill their duties.
And so this is the ideal. Now you will have people who will come to you. And certainly they have come to me. And they said that, you know, not all of the Sufis were political, not all of them were actively resisting and all of that. And I say that 100%. That's not the argument I'm trying to make. There were certainly different types of these Sufi leaders. Some of them were apolitical, some of them were more quietest than others.
Some of them really were more reclusive than others. And that's absolutely true. But at the same time they weren't feigning being apolitical and at the same time going around and allying with the princes and the tyrants and the state apparatus of their time. So if you want to be apolitical, then sure, by all means be a hermit, follow that tradition and that's between you and Allah and that's fine. But there is a higher ideal here and I don't want to want people to just by saying, you know, there was all sorts of types of people in the past who were more quietist and more subordinate and more pragmatic. Sure. But don't make that the ideal because I think that would be intellectually dishonest
[00:36:06] Speaker A: if, if we're to look at kind of the map of what could be considered at least claims of Tasawuf today, how would you kind of, if you were to draw a map and what we have these towering figures. But in terms of contemporary, like in terms of our time, what would you say are the.
Maybe the spectrum from what is authentic. And by authentic I mean true to the tradition in all its diversity. As you pointed out, there were people who were hermits or lived in a hole in the woods and you know, they were not part of atarika, they were not involved in. And there is this part of the tradition. But you know, we have people like Hamza, Yusuf Zaytuna, sort of folks who identify as kind of neo traditionalist in quotes, I'll put that, you know, Zayd Shakir, these sorts of people who do talk about Sufism and identify as Sort of neo traditionalist. That's maybe a camp. Could we say that?
What would the camps be if we were to do that? If you draw us a little bit of a map of the spectrum today and where do you feel like the roadmap is for Muslims today?
Are we kind of in a place without necessarily a living tasawwuf tradition to, or do we need, do we need to revive it or is it still among us?
[00:37:45] Speaker B: Well, Hamzulillah, the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam said al khayru qa' imun fi ummmati. You know, always that the goodness persists in my ummah until the end of time.
There's never a shortage of prophetic exemplars of people who embody, you know, both Jalal and Jamal, those who balance knowledge and action, those who are trying their best to not capitulate totally to the dictates of the state and preserve their own, you know, sovereign ways of being and knowing. And so that is exactly where I would, if I were to identify paths, then this would be it. I've always said that there's, you know, kind of state beholden scholarship and there is sovereign scholarship, there is a prophetic ways and there's profane ways and they can both look very much Muslim. They can both have ijazat and turbans and give retreats and teach and establish institutions.
And so it's very hard for lay people to discern, okay, is this good for my soul or is it not right? And I'm not saying that there is no benefit to be had at all from this neo traditionalist utopia that they try to build. But the irony is that in trying to build this pure and pristine return to the tradition, return to the Ijaza system and build this more classic, this classical ways of knowing to resist the moral rot of our time and modernity and TikTok and all those bad things. According to them, what you are doing is you're still reacting. And that is my biggest critique, is that it is still drenched with anxiety.
And so it ends up resembling more of a Christian right wing Islam than an organic, embodied, prophetic and rooted Islam that ultimately should have no fear and should actually move in the world without reactionary identitarian politics and should actually be the answer and be the lighthouse. And so we see this in the Arab world too. And in South Asia there are kind of, maybe we see in the news more of the state aligned scholars because they're the ones who have more funding, they're the ones who have more power, they're the ones who, like Sayyidina Nuh son, they ran to the mountain because they didn't want to be called terrorists. They didn't want to be put on any FBI watch list. So they throw their oppressed brethren under the bus and they start internalizing war on terror rhetoric and saying this is extremism. This is, you know, this is any kind of combination of Muslim and political awareness or activism in the world is rendered suspect to them. It's rendered as modernist. And it doesn't obey Waliul Amr. But when we, the Waliul Amr being whoever, is an authority of the time. But again, the largest aberration is that when you demand people to obey, what are you demanding them to actually obey?
The person of authority should obey Allah and his messenger as a condition. And can we really say that under the secular nation state that these secular princes of the Arab world are actually, in the classical Islamic sense? I don't think we can say that. Right. And so this is the irony of all of this, is that it presumes itself to be a classical and traditional and pure and pragmatic and wise, when in reality it is very reactionary to modernity and it actually adopts postmodern categories such as, you know, that resemble the postmodern categories and more Christian right wing kind of identifiers rather than truly Islamic and traditional categories.
[00:41:58] Speaker A: In one of your commemorations of Malcolm X, El Hajmalech Al Shabazz, you write that pretty much every Muslim organization, every mosque, will issue a statement of some kind celebrating Malcolm X, but that he wouldn't be welcome if he were here today.
And how does that speak to kind of this disconnect between maybe the historical memory as a superficial memory of oh yes, this is our legacy, and then in reality the material situation being completely disconnected?
[00:42:36] Speaker B: Yeah, I think that when I wrote that I was, you know, a little bit angry for Hajj Malik and I had a Ghaira, you know, like a protectiveness towards him because if he's remembered for one thing, he's remembered for his honesty. And I think a lot of us, when we move in the Muslim community in the Masajid and we still find the very kind of meek and docile rhetoric. And so somebody who comes to puncture that veneer of normalcy and putting up appearances and pretending, I don't think someone like that would be welcome. Whereas, you know, Malcolm was always very suspicious and actually called out what he called novocaine religion.
Religion, that kind of sedated you. That gave you the illusion that you're good just because you belong to this faith and, you know, just getting validation from your community and just feeling pious because you go through the motions of, you know, prayer and almsgiving and hajj and, you know, these five star Umrah packages.
But what is your faith actually doing? You know what I mean? Is it giving you the sense of self worship that, you know, that are you worshiping Islam instead of Allah?
And so again, Islam is a path of being a stranger and, you know, holding on to faith like, like it's hot coals.
And so yes, Islam is meant to be a refuge and give tranquility to the believers and peace. And it should, it should be a source of comfort for us in the world.
But at the same time, we can't stay in that comfort for too long because that becomes kind of a lullaby, you know, rather than.
The hot rock that was on Sayyidina Bilal's stomach or the, you know, the entrails that were left on the Prophet's back as he bowed. And when Sayyidah Fatima, she came and removed those intestines from his back, her beloved back. And so this is the kind of Islam I know. Yeah,
[00:45:00] Speaker A: this is a great connection point to.
In the historical tradition, the narrative of Karbala was not limited only to Shi' I or proto Shi' I veneration. It was the, you know, Abu Hanifa famously, you know, was supporting the rebellion of Zayd against the imperial Islam that was developing at the time.
The narrative of Karbala, of Imam Hussein of Zaynab in the court of Damascus.
What do you feel is kind of, if we could say, a sort of Husseini or Zainabi ethic that comes out of this.
And what role does this narrative and its legacy serve offer us today?
[00:46:05] Speaker B: Yeah, I think if more Muslims, especially Sunnis, took the time to learn about the events at Karbala, we will realize that every day is still Karbala and every land is Ashura and that it is really, rather than being a sectarian point of departure, actually it has the potential to unite all Muslims under the banner of really, truly loving Sayyidina Muhammad and those whom he loved. Right? He said Hussain minni waana min Hussain. Ahaballah man Ahabbal Hussaina. I am from Hussain and Hussain is from me. And Allah loves anybody who loves Imam Hussain. And what does it mean to love Imam Hussain? It means to walk his path, right? And his footsteps. And I recall the words of Ali Shariati who was actually cited by Khadr Adnan the Great.
They call him the, you know, the greatest.
He led.
He led the battle of the empty stomachs and he led many, many hunger strikes in prison. I think they reached over 50 days.
And those who accuse us Palestinians of being violent, believe me, we tried every nonviolent means under the sun and it killed many, many before us who tried to resist injustice. And Khadr Adnan, really, I urge everybody to read about him. He passed away in prison due to extreme hunger. And when he was alive and when he. Well, he's still alive as a shaheed. But I mean, when he gave an interview in between his arrests, he said, quoting Shariati, hussainiyyan ala tariq al Shahada fakun zaynabiyyan fit tabligh. Like, if you cannot be Hussaini in your path of struggle and sacrifice, then at the very least be Zainabi in your truth telling.
And so this is exactly what inspired my substack sermons at the court. It's actually a homage to my beloved great aunt, Syeda Zainab.
And she was defiantly known to confront her brother and her family's killers at the court of Yazid in Damascus.
And famously they tried to taunt her and say, look what Allah has done to you and your family. And she replied this beautiful response that echoed through the ages. She said, I only see from Allah, but beauty, it's for you, it's you humankind who are committing such horrible atrocities.
And in a beautiful kind of 360 of sorts of. I recently, not recently, for two years now, had the honor of befriending the Khansa of Gaza, the mother of the four martyrs, Dr. Ala Al Khatrawi, the mother of Yamin or Qida Carmel.
And they are her beautiful Shuhada. And she is a poetess from Gaza. And she also invokes this line of this line by Sayyida Zainab. I have seen nothing from Allah except beauty.
And even though she suffered the most unspeakable horror of losing your beloved children, she still holds on to the love of Allah.
And her faith has triumphed over the monstrosity of her children's killers. And this is the kind of faith that I hope we should all aspire to.
[00:49:55] Speaker A: And in one of your writings, you referenced that she actually was engaging with the poetry of Ahmad Ahmaduamba.
[00:50:04] Speaker B: Yes, yeah. And another and another Subhanallah, you know, providence and full circle coming of sorts. For I'm just always amazed at how generous Allah is in terms of always giving us these beautiful connections. And she this is a story on my substack if your listeners would like to read about it. It's reading Ahmad and Gaza. And so the story goes that Allah was so distraught naturally that she would never answer her phone after her children were killed. She didn't want to talk to anybody, naturally. She was in a state of shock and grief.
And the only thing really that was able to yank her out of her state of utter despair was her friend calling her and telling her just one thing. Allah.
Don't you say you love the Prophet? Don't you want to be like him? He also lost his children, so be happy that you are like him. And then she sent her the lines. Actually Allah herself found these lines from Sheikh Ahmadamba who said, and be tough and don't show your sorrow such that people think that you are drowning in grace, that you are very. You're happy. So at that moment, Sheikh Ahmad's lines transformed Allah and gave her that prophetic strength that, you know, I will be well for Allah's sake, that I will move on to walk on the footsteps of the Prophet.
[00:51:46] Speaker A: I want to come back to that footsteps point in the next question. But before that I just want to touch on how would you, because it's such a central focus is, and obviously it is really make, as you point out, it makes sort of these distinctions between those who, you know, pay lip service and not clear.
How would you characterize the centrality of Palestine and Al Quds and Jerusalem for the Ummah as a whole, for the Muslim community as a whole?
[00:52:22] Speaker B: Yeah, I think that Falasteen is the locus of our awakening as Muslims. It can be, if you let it, it can be the ultimate sheikh, if you will. This is a little bit of poetic license on my end, but why Palestine and why is it so central?
Well, if we're talking about this disorder that we're living in, Palestine stayed in the colonial matrix when the whole Muslim world moved on into the Sykes Pico world order and accepting the myth of the secular nation state of the post colonial reality. Palestine was always like, no, that is a myth, that is a lie. All of you in your little silos, you need to wake up. Muslims have no real sovereignty. There is no real integrity. And we've seen this happen. We've seen all of these states. Instead of helping, even since 1948, the Arabs have already betrayed Palestine and moved on into their own national interests. So one Palestine is the ultimate antidote of the poison of nationalism. So if any Muslim wants to rid themselves of that poison. They have to look there and read that history.
But even more metaphysically and on a kind of a Quranic level and on the level of, you know, the history of humanity and the history of revelation, the Bayt Al Maqdis was the first qibla, right? And so when people kind of say it's the third holiest place in Islam, I kind of cringe because it kind of gives this impression that third means third less important than Mecca and Medina.
But we don't realize that when it was the Qibla for Muslims, why did it change to Mecca? Well, because the Bani Israel of the time during the Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam's era, were upset by the sharing right of that qibla. They didn't want this, this descendant of Ismail to have the same qibla as them. So it was very much motivated by the supremacist, tribalist, chosen people complex.
And this is why Allah changed it, right? He said, we see you O Prophet, turning your face towards heaven in distress. Now we will make you towards direction of prayer that will please you. Qiblatan tardaha in Surat al Baqaram.
So basically, when we Muslims orient ourselves back to that first Qibla of Islam, we are reorienting back to an Islam of universals, of an Islam of prophetic mercy to all humankind. An Islam that can represent an antidote to Judeo Christian supremacy. Muslim presence in Jerusalem was always tied to guardianship of other faith groups. When Syedina Omar opened Bayt Al Maqdis, he asked where are the Jews? And he was concerned like where did they go? And the Christians at the time had sent them all away.
And so he even didn't pray in the Christian churches so that later on there wouldn't be kind of a move to take over spaces of Christians and Jews. So this is the kind of guardianship and this trusteeship for all of humanity that the world is really aching for, right? We really need now a world order that is not so supremacist and so arrogant and so anti human. And we have the final revelation leader for all of humanity is Rahmatan Alameen, the mercy to all of humankind.
So when we have our qibla back on Jerusalem, it reorients our Islam away from culture wars, away from just, you know, this tribalist thinking, nationalist thinking and reminds us of the higher calling of what, you know, the final revelation really represents. It's supposed to be a protective shield and a mercy for all of humans, not just Muslims.
[00:56:56] Speaker A: And to connect this Point back to the conversation we were having about Sufism, Tasawwuf and kind of quietism. You know, we see many imams, preachers and some incline Salafi. Some say the Sufi, some are state appointed, some aren't, maybe imams. Sometimes people in the government of different Arab or non Muslim countries who will say, you know, we have to pray for Gaza or we must support our brothers and sisters in Gaza, we must, you know, but it stops there. And maybe they'll do a fundraiser to raise some money for something. But this kind of lip service point, can you kind of explain this phenomenon? I mean, you know, you mentioned the abandoning of the Palestinian people in 1948, but how do we understand this? It's not just limited necessarily to kind of the quote unquote Sufi imams. It's also those that say that they're Salafi or as you said, they're kind of this maybe right wing Islam.
Could you talk about this a little bit?
[00:58:04] Speaker B: Yeah, I think you're talking about the Madkhali Salafism, the class of scholars that are, you know, certainly not Sufi by any stretch of the imagination, but also similarly preach this unconditional obedience to whatever the ruler says or wants.
And I think that this is a very hypocritical stance because we have seen recently, especially after the war on Iran, the same scholars who said that it is Khuruj, it is forbidden for any Muslim to support any resistance to injustice in Palestine, is now actually obligated to fight in Yemen.
And some scholars have actually blessed those good soldiers on the American vessel, Al Batriyut. Right. So it's kind of really revealing itself how absurd this is. And it really does boil down to, like I said, this differentiation between state beholden scholarship and sovereign scholarship.
And so it really does confirm that your stances on Palestine have to do with your Aqeedah. They have to do a lot with your belief, the level of your belief. Because Palestine is kind of the litmus test for faith. And a lot of the, kind of the, the sheikhs in wolves clothing will tell you, oh, you know, they've made Palestine as if it's an idol to be worshipped. As if like it's. So these people who are pro justice, they're so woke, they care too much about Palestine that they are actually compromising their faith. The irony is actually that these people that you are blaming for going too far for Palestine are the ones who are trying to wrestle Islam away from idol worship, the idol worship of nationalism and the obedience to unconditional obedience to secular rulers.
So in a way, Palestine is more iconoclastic in its efforts to remind us that nationalism and obedience and all of these keep the Ummah very weak. And it has the potential to unite the Ummah. And so this is what the powers that be don't want. So it's only natural that they would fight the Palestinian cause, because if Palestine is free, then Cairo, Amman, Riyadh, etc. Will all by necessity have to be free as well.
[01:00:57] Speaker A: So I wanted to draw back to this point about walking in the footsteps of the Prophet sallallahu alaihi you write a lot about in your dissertation, you focused on Sheikh Tal's discussion of the living Prophet and you reference it again in your later work and you say, you know, to modern Muslims, do they truly know their Prophet as a living link?
And you referenced the Quranic notion that those who die in the cause of Allah are not dead, they're living. And of course, how could this not be true for the Prophet? So what does this mean? What does the concept of a living Prophet mean to you?
And how do you understand its significance and the power that it holds?
[01:01:49] Speaker B: Hmm, That's a big, big question. And I think if I were to be honest, it is the core locus of what motivates me and what, you know, this kind of love, this living love is what forces me to show up every day and speak as truthfully as I can and work as hard as I can to resist tyranny in the name of Islam and tribalism and stasis.
And so paradoxically, people think that this heightened spiritual connection with Sayyidina Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam produces this more static, esoteric, quiet kind of Islam. But in reality we see that time and time again all of the figures, the revolutionary figures, whether they, you know, Salahuddin, or the anti colonial warriors like Amir Abdelkader Al Jazairi, Imam Shamil Hajj, Omar Fouti Hamad Abdel Hassan in Somalia, what combined all of these men, and certainly there were women as well in this rich prophetic tradition, is actually their radical love. And when I say radical again, it shouldn't give you alarm bells of this like kind of leftist Marxist inclination. It's actually, it's kind of a connection where even any average Muslim learns in Sunday school or whatever that when we send salawat upon the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam and Allah sends these salawats on our behalf and we are responded right with this salat and Salam and every Muslim when they sit down in prayer, what is the culmination of prayer?
Salal ibrahimiyya, right? Allahumma Salli alayhi Sayyidina Muhammad wa ala ali sayyidina Muhammad.
It is almost like the crown jewel. It's almost as if the Salah is when we sit down and we connect right directly with the Prophet. So certainly this idea of a more heightened connection with the Prophet is not new at all. It's a central, you know, basic Islamic doctrine and creed and it was heavily developed in the past by scholars such as, you know, Tirmidhi, Bayhaqi, Ibn Arabi and Suyuti. So this was very normative. Like you wouldn't even have to convince a pre colonial Muslim that, you know, to read Dala il Khairaat. The most widely read devotional text after the Quran in the Muslim world was this Dala al Khairat, this book of Salawat that was even understood to have medicinal properties.
So this was always a hallmark of Muslim societies to really love the Prophet. Sallallahu alaihi wasallam in a vivid way. And, and we see, you know, in the 18th century onwards, instead of it becoming a central Islamic edict, it's, it kind of became more reserved for the so called spiritual elite. And so it becomes more and more of an esoteric thing. And again that can't be divorced from the colonial gaze because when the colonial officers looked at these so called mystics and Sufis and call them heretics, dervishes, you know, that kind of language got adopted by modernist reformers such as Muhammad Abdul and others who started seeing this whole thing with suspicion. And that is why we have this more rationalist, secular rejection of devotion and spiritual connection. And so it's a conundrum. We have a lot of decolonizing to do.
And I think that Salawat is a great way to do that because it reminds you that any Muslim has to have, has to love the Prophet more than they love themselves as per the Hadith. And that the second part of the Shahada is kind of an activator for Tawheed. Because if we're truly to say La ilaha illallah, then we have to show it in action through walking the path of Muhammadan Rus.
[01:06:19] Speaker A: Thank you so much Farah for joining us here at the Maidan.
Really grateful for the conversation and for listeners. You can find more from Dr. Sharif on her substack sermons at court.substack.com and I believe recently launched a court fellowship program for people who want to be more involved and engaged.
[01:06:47] Speaker B: Yes, thank you, Robert. That's available for people who upgrade on their subscription on my substack. And it's really an informal opportunity for us to learn together where I provide bi weekly lessons and we discuss themes from the substack. So everybody's welcome. And yes, thank you so much for this wonderful interview. And to Maidan and Robert and Allah, bless every good that you are doing,
[01:07:12] Speaker A: of course. Thank you so much for joining us. We look forward to seeing what you do at the next stage of your work.
[01:07:19] Speaker B: Thank you. Thank you so much.